Witch’s Brew Punch Recipe

If you love Halloween parties or just want a fun, spooky drink that gets everyone smiling, this Witch’s Brew Punch Recipe is an absolute must-try. I first made it for a last-minute get-together, and it was an instant hit—fruity, fizzy, and just the right kind of eerie with those gummy worms swimming around. Keep reading, because I’ll walk you through exactly how to make this fan-freaking-tastic punch that’s as simple to throw together as it is to drink!

this …

Ingredients & Why They Work

When you look at the ingredients for this Witch’s Brew Punch Recipe, you might think it’s just a simple mix—but each part plays an important role. The bubbly Sprite gives it sparkle and sweetness, the pineapple juice adds tropical tang, and the lime sherbet makes it creamy and frothy, tying everything together with a chill that’s perfect for parties.

• Sprite: Provides a crisp, fizzy base that’s sweet but not overpowering, making it the perfect mixer.
• Pineapple juice: Adds a punchy fruity flavor that cuts through the sweetness and keeps things refreshing.
• Lime sherbet: This is the magical ingredient that gives the punch a creamy texture and that classic tangy-lime note.
• Green gel food coloring: Just a few drops turn the whole punch an eerie, glowing green—perfect for the witchy theme.
• Gummy worms: Classic creepy-crawly garnish that floats in the punch and keeps guests giggling.
• Plastic spiders: For decoration only, but they really pump up the Halloween vibe when you float them around or place on the edge of cups.

Tweak to Your Taste

One of the best things about this Witch’s Brew Punch Recipe is how customizable it is. I sometimes like it a bit more tart, so I toss in a splash of fresh lime juice. Other times, I go heavier on the sherbet for a creamier, almost float-like punch. Feel free to experiment—it’s all about what makes your party guests reach for seconds!

• Variation: I’ve swapped pineapple juice for orange juice when I ran out, and it was just as tasty—just a bit sweeter and less tropical.
• Alcohol option: If your guests like a grown-up twist, try adding a cup of rum or vodka to the mix for an adult-only version.
• Dietary modification: Use a sugar-free lemon-lime soda to lighten up the punch while keeping that fizzy goodness.

Step-by-Step: How I Make Witch’s Brew Punch Recipe

Step 1: Scoop the Sherbet

I start by dropping generous scoops of lime sherbet into a large punch bowl. The best part? You can easily adjust the amount depending on how creamy and frothy you want your punch. The sherbet will slowly melt and give a fantastic texture—plus, it cools your punch without watering it down.

Step 2: Add the Green Magic

Next, a couple of drops of green gel food coloring go right on top of the sherbet. I like gel food coloring because it gives a vibrant hue without thinning the punch. Stir gently just enough to swirl the color—don’t overmix or you’ll lose the frothy texture.

Step 3: Pour the Juices

Pour in the pineapple juice first—this adds the fruity backbone of the punch—then follow it up with the Sprite for fizz and shine. The cold soda bubbles reactivate the sherbet’s creaminess, making the whole mixture smile-worthy.

Step 4: Add the Gummy Worms & Spiders

Finally, toss in a handful of gummy worms to float in the punch bowl, and scatter some plastic spiders on top for creepy fun. Pro tip: I always keep extra gummy worms handy because they disappear faster than the punch itself!

How to Serve Witch’s Brew Punch Recipe

Garnishes

I always go for gummy worms straight in the punch bowl and in each cup—kids (and adults) love fishing them out. I also tuck in a plastic spider on the rim of the glass for some extra creepy fun. If you want to get even more festive, slice thin rounds of lime or lemon and float them on top for a pop of color and a little extra zing.

Side Dishes

This punch pairs wonderfully with finger foods like mini sandwiches, cheese and cracker platters, or even creepy Halloween treats like deviled eggs with olive “spiders.” I’ve also served it alongside pumpkin-shaped sugar cookies for an extra festive touch.

Creative Ways to Present

I once set up a “mad scientist” lab table with dry ice nearby for fog effects, making the punch look like it was steaming out of the bowl. I also love using a hollowed-out pumpkin as a punch bowl for Halloween parties—it’s such a showstopper and adds a natural vibe that guests always rave about.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Leftover Witch’s Brew punch keeps surprisingly well in the fridge for a day or two—just cover it tightly and keep it chilled. Once the sherbet melts fully, it becomes more like a fruity soda, which is still delicious but less frothy.

Freezing

I don’t recommend freezing the punch since the carbonation from the Sprite can get lost, and the sherbet texture won’t hold up. Instead, I prefer making it fresh right before serving to capture that perfect frothy magic.

Reheating

This punch is best served cold, so reheating isn’t really needed. If you do have leftovers, just give it a gentle stir and serve chilled again rather than heating it up—it preserves the flavor better.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

I can’t tell you how many times this Witch’s Brew Punch Recipe has saved the day at parties—quick, impressive, and loved by everyone. It’s such a cheerful way to get into the Halloween spirit or to just add fun fizz to any gathering. I promise you, once you make it, you’ll be the go-to host for every spooky season ahead. Grab your ingredients and get brewing—your guests will thank you!

Print